
Your Guide to Trick-or-Treating Around Pittsburgh
October 29, 2026
10 Pittsburgh restaurants we still miss, and 10 new spots every real foodie should visit
By Tom Pollard
I don’t pretend that the local restaurants on the following list, all of which closed over the last 10 years, were anything but what they were: places we enjoyed, places where memories were made, and places we wish had stuck around a little longer. What would we give to visit some of them one more time?
Truth is, I started this list and then handed it over to my foodie friends with an invitation. They could add a place they thought belonged, but to do that, they had to take one of mine off. Here are the lists I ended up with.
You’ll notice 2020 shows up a lot on this list. Four of these 10 restaurants closed the year the pandemic hit.
They Go: 10 Places We Still Miss
1. Six Penn Kitchen
Downtown | Closed 2018
For nearly 13 years, Six Penn held down the corner of Sixth Street and Penn Avenue, right across from Heinz Hall. It was one of the restaurants that made dinner before a show in the Cultural District feel like part of the night out.
Remember the “Six Penn Circus” dessert platter, cotton candy and all.
2. Café Sam
Bloomfield | Closed 2018
A converted brick house on Baum Boulevard, with a front porch, a rooftop patio and a mannequin named Samantha holding court at the bar. For about 30 years, it was one of the most charmingly unusual dining rooms in the city.
Remember the warm bread and that famous pesto oil.
3. Peter’s Pub
Oakland | Closed 2018
For more than four decades, Pitt students, alumni and game-day crowds called Peter’s their place. The family that owned it decided to retire and poured the last round in May 2018.
Remember the wings, or the Cardiac Burger, if you dared.
4. Spoon
East Liberty | Closed 2020
Chef Brian Pekarcik’s Spoon opened in 2010, when that corner of East Liberty was just starting to come back to life. It became the place you booked for anniversaries and good news. It closed during the pandemic and never reopened.
Remember the Spoon Bar, the chocolate dessert worth saving room for.
5. Green Forest Brazilian Restaurant
Penn Hills | Closed 2020
Twenty years of Brazilian grilled meats off Rodi Road, plus more weddings, Sweet 16s and birthday dinners than anyone could count. It served its last meal on Father’s Day 2020, just months before its 20th anniversary.
Remember the skewers of grilled meat that just kept coming, and the feijoada.
6. Thai Place
Wexford | Closed 2024
When it opened in 1989, the owners believed it was the first Thai restaurant in the Pittsburgh area. After 35 years, the couple who ran it retired, and plenty of longtime regulars took the news as hard as they did.
Missing their Pad Thai? Before closing, they launched a line of bottled sauces, Pad Thai included.
7. Blue Flame
Jefferson Hills | Closed 2024
Family-owned since 1956, the Blue Flame on Route 51 fed generations of breakfast and lunch regulars and kept drivers smiling with the witty messages on its roadside sign. When it closed, the Heinz History Center asked for the sign.
Remember: no signature dish, just honest diner food, ice cream and that sign.
8. Superior Motors
Braddock | Closed 2020
Chef Kevin Sousa built it inside a former car dealership with help from more than 2,000 Kickstarter backers. For a few years, it put Braddock on the national dining map, and Time magazine even named it one of the World’s Greatest Places.
Remember a menu that never sat still: poké one visit, turnip gnocchi the next.
9. Grant Bar
Millvale | Closed 2025
Ninety years, three generations of families, and famous homemade pies. The last night was November 29, 2025, and the kitchen baked well over a hundred pies that final week.
Remember the coconut cream pie.
10. The Original Hot Dog Shop
Oakland | Closed 2020
“The O” opened in 1960, a short walk from Forbes Field, and spent 60 years feeding Pittsburgh hot dogs and fries piled high, often long after midnight. It closed quietly in April 2020.
Remember the fries: a mountain of them, cooked in peanut oil.
One More Farewell on the Horizon: Joe’s Rusty Nail
Bellevue | Closure Announced for 2026
As I was finishing this piece, Joe’s Rusty Nail in Bellevue announced it will close at the end of the year after more than four decades. Get there while you can.
I’ve read some pieces saying the city won’t be the same once a few famed eateries vanish. I want to assure you: our favorite places may be gone, but new ones are popping up everywhere.
I must admit, I’ve only been to a few of them. Thank goodness I know folks who get out more often than I do. I came up with an initial list and asked my friends whether I’d missed a place that belongs on a list of 10 new spots every real foodie should visit. Just like the list above, if they added a place, they had to remove one.
They Come: 10 New Spots Worth a Visit
1. Fig & Ash
North Side | Opened 2020
Wood-fired comfort food on East Ohio Street in Deutschtown. The owners spent years rebuilding the space, then opened in the middle of the pandemic, and it has been a neighborhood favorite ever since.
Look for the short rib and pork belly meatloaf.
2. Hemlock House
Regent Square | Opened 2023
Josh Sickels, the musician behind Rockaway Pizzeria, turned the old Map Room on South Braddock Avenue into a moody, Twin Peaks–inspired hangout serving bold, irreverent pub food and cocktails, with weekend brunch too.
Look for the crab and bacon hushpuppies.
3. ShadoBeni
North Side | Opened 2022
Ulric Joseph’s vegan Trinidadian cooking, including doubles and roti, graduated from the local farmers markets to its own storefront on Brighton Road.
Order the doubles.
4. EYV
North Side | Opened 2023
Chef Mike Godlewski puts vegetables at the center of the plate (the name stands for “Eat Your Veggies”), using produce from Western Pennsylvania and eastern Ohio farms whenever he can.
Look for the cabbage “pastrami,” which eats like a steak.
5. Café Momentum
Downtown | Opened 2023
Great food with a mission. This nonprofit restaurant near Market Square gives young people ages 15 to 19 who have been involved in the justice system paid internships to learn every part of the restaurant business.
Order the smoked fried chicken.
6. Balvanera
Strip District | Opened 2023
An Argentine brasserie in a restored Smallman Street warehouse, serving empanadas, steaks with fresh chimichurri and a long list of Argentine wines.
Start with the empanadas.
7. Lilith
Shadyside | Opened 2023
Chefs Jamilka Borges and Dianne DeStefano cook coastal food with Puerto Rican and Sicilian roots in a small, colorful dining room. Reservations go fast.
Don’t skip the yuca pierogi.
8. Wise County Biscuits and Cafe
North Side | Opened 2023
Appalachian home cooking built on buttermilk biscuits made from owner James Wolfe’s grandmother’s recipes. It started at farmers markets before settling into a cozy café in Allegheny West.
Order a biscuit sandwich, with a side of chow chow.
9. Fet-Fisk
Bloomfield | Opened 2024
Nik Forsberg’s Nordic seafood and oyster bar went from a popular pop-up to a national darling, landing on best-restaurant lists from the New York Times, Eater and Bon Appétit.
Look for the pickled mackerel with smoky beet purée.
10. Palm Palm
Shadyside | Opened 2025
Palm Springs and Palm Beach glamour on Centre Avenue, with coastal small plates and a serious cocktail program. Yelp named it one of the best new restaurants in America for 2026.
Try the truffle spaghettios.
Your Turn: Share Your Pittsburgh Restaurant Memories!
As you can see by now, these lists are very subjective. I didn’t put them together to tell you which places are the most important. I’m sure I could find kind words from professionals about all 20 of these restaurants, but I would rather hear what you have to say.
Do you have a favorite memory of one of the restaurants we lost? Or have you visited one of the newer spots and found something worth recommending?
If you have 10 to 30 words to say about any restaurant on either list, I’d love to hear them!
Let me know whether you want your name listed or would rather stay anonymous. And please, I’d love to hear your words, however flawed, instead of a chatbot’s.
You can also send your memories directly to info@positivelypittsburgh.com.
Share Your Pittsburgh Restaurant Memories!
Tell us about a restaurant you remember or recommend. Your story might be featured on Positively Pittsburgh!
What’s Next
Soon on the Positively Pittsburgh Podcast, I’ll sit down with a couple of foodie friends to talk about these lists: what I got right, and what they would have done differently.
And this winter, I’m asking for your help finding the best locally owned, family-run restaurant in the greater Pittsburgh area. Nominations open in December, and voting follows in the new year. Stay tuned.
This list was put together in November 2026. I can’t guarantee that any of the places on it will be there forever.




